"Vatican exonerates the Knights Templar after 700 years." Headlines like this have circulated since 2001, when a forgotten parchment was found in the Vatican's archives, and again in 2007, when the Vatican published the trial records in a luxury facsimile edition. The real story is more interesting, and more precise, than the headlines.
This article explains what the Chinon Parchment is, what it actually says, how the Vatican's 2007 publication came about, and why historians describe it as an absolution rather than an exoneration. It also covers the long, complicated relationship between the Templars and the papacy, from their founding privileges to their suppression in 1312.

The Templars and the Papacy: A Special Relationship
From the beginning, the Knights Templar depended on the popes. The order was founded in Jerusalem around 1119–1120, and its Rule was approved at the Council of Troyes in 1129 with the support of Bernard of Clairvaux. In 1139 Pope Innocent II issued Omne datum optimum, which exempted the Templars from the authority of local bishops and placed them directly under the pope. Later bulls, Milites Templi (1144) and Militia Dei (1145), added more privileges, including their own priests and cemeteries.
These privileges made the order powerful, but they also made enemies. Bishops resented losing tithes and control. When the crusader states collapsed after the fall of Acre in 1291, the Templars had fewer defenders and many critics. Their only real protector was the pope, and in 1307 the pope was weak.
1307: A King Arrests the Pope's Knights

Artistic illustration (AI-generated).
On Friday, 13 October 1307, King Philip IV of France had the Templars in his kingdom arrested and charged with heresy, idolatry and immorality. We tell that story in detail in What Happened to the Knights Templar on Friday the 13th?
Pope Clement V, a Gascon elected in 1305 and living in France rather than Rome, protested that the king had no right to arrest members of an exempt religious order. But Clement was in a weak position. Philip's ministers had already humiliated Pope Boniface VIII, and Clement chose to take control of the investigation rather than oppose it outright. In November 1307 his bull Pastoralis praeeminentiae ordered Templars to be arrested throughout Christendom.
After Jacques de Molay and other leaders retracted their confessions in front of papal cardinals in December 1307, Clement suspended the inquisitors' work. Philip responded with pressure and propaganda, and in the summer of 1308 king and pope met at Poitiers. Some 72 Templars were brought before the pope there. The order's senior leaders were held at the royal castle of Chinon, said to be too ill to travel.
The Chinon Parchment: What It Says

Between 17 and 20 August 1308, three cardinals, Bérenger Frédol, Étienne de Suisy and Landolfo Brancacci, questioned the Grand Master Jacques de Molay and four other leaders at Chinon: Raimbaud de Caron, Hugues de Pairaud, Geoffroi de Charney and Geoffroi de Gonneville.
The parchment records that the leaders admitted some irregularities at the order's reception ceremony, such as denying Christ or spitting near the cross "in words only, not in spirit", while rejecting the more lurid charges. They asked for mercy, and the cardinals, acting with the pope's authority, absolved them and restored them to communion with the Church.
Absolution, not exoneration
This distinction matters. Absolution meant the individuals were reconciled to the Church after confessing and doing penance. It did not declare that the charges were false, and it did not acquit the order as an institution. What the document does show is that Clement V, at least in 1308, did not regard the Templar leaders as heretics and seems to have hoped to reform the order rather than destroy it.
How it was lost and found
The parchment was misfiled in the Vatican archives for centuries. An abridged copy was known, but the original was identified in 2001 by Barbara Frale, an Italian palaeographer working in what was then called the Vatican Secret Archives. She published her analysis in the Journal of Medieval History in 2004. (Pope Francis renamed the institution the Vatican Apostolic Archive in 2019.)
The 2007 Vatican Publication: Processus contra Templarios

Artistic illustration (AI-generated).
In October 2007 the Vatican archives, with the publisher Scrinium, released Processus contra Templarios, a facsimile edition of the papal records of the Templar trials, including the Chinon Parchment. Only 799 copies were printed, priced at around 5,900 euros each, aimed at research libraries and collectors. Vatican officials explained that faithful reproductions would let scholars study the documents while protecting the fragile originals.
Media coverage of the launch produced the "Templars pardoned" headlines. In reality, the Vatican did not issue a new judgement, a pardon or an apology. It published historical documents that had been known to specialists since Frale's discovery. There has been no formal papal apology to the Templars.
Why the Pope Still Dissolved the Order

If Clement absolved the leaders in 1308, why did he suppress the order four years later? The answer lies in politics. Philip IV kept up the pressure, threatening a posthumous heresy trial of Boniface VIII that would have damaged the papacy. Templars across France continued to be tried by local bishops, and in May 1310 the Archbishop of Sens burned 54 brothers who had withdrawn their confessions.
At the Council of Vienne, the bull Vox in excelso (22 March 1312) suppressed the order. Its wording is careful: Clement acted "not by way of judicial sentence, but by way of provision or apostolic ordinance". In other words, the pope never formally condemned the Templars as heretics. He dissolved them because the scandal had made the order, in his view, impossible to save. The bull Ad providam then assigned its property to the Knights Hospitaller. For more on Clement's role, see our article on the dissolution of the order.
Trials Beyond France
The outcome of the Templar trials depended heavily on where the brothers lived. In France, where the king controlled the process, torture produced confessions. In Cyprus, Aragon, Castile, Portugal and much of the Holy Roman Empire, investigations found little evidence of heresy. English inquisitors obtained few confessions until torture was finally authorised in 1311. In Portugal, King Denis protected the order's property, and in 1319 the pope approved the new Order of Christ, which inherited the Templars' Portuguese houses and many of their brothers.
The Price: Fire in Paris

The absolution at Chinon did not save Jacques de Molay. On 18 March 1314, when he and Geoffroi de Charney were sentenced to life imprisonment, both publicly declared the order innocent and withdrew their confessions. As relapsed heretics in the eyes of the royal council, they were burned that evening on an island in the Seine. Their story is told in The Last Stand of Jacques de Molay.
What the Chinon Parchment Changes, and What It Doesn't
- It changes our view of Clement V. He is often seen as Philip's puppet, but the parchment shows he tried, at least for a time, to protect the order's leaders.
- It confirms that the Church never formally convicted the Templars of heresy.
- It does not prove that the Templars had no irregular customs, and it does not reverse the suppression of 1312.
- It does not support claims of secret treasure, hidden bloodlines or a surviving underground order.
The Order traces its founding to around 1119, the date printed on our Templar Knight MagSafe Clear Case – EST. 1119.
Timeline
- 1139: Omne datum optimum places the Templars under the pope's direct authority.
- 13 October 1307: Philip IV orders the arrests in France.
- 22 November 1307: Pastoralis praeeminentiae orders arrests across Christendom.
- 17–20 August 1308: cardinals absolve Molay and other leaders at Chinon.
- 22 March 1312: Vox in excelso suppresses the order without a verdict of heresy.
- 18 March 1314: Jacques de Molay and Geoffroi de Charney are burned in Paris.
- 2001: Barbara Frale identifies the Chinon Parchment in the Vatican archives.
- October 2007: the Vatican publishes Processus contra Templarios.

Frequently Asked Questions
Did the Vatican exonerate the Knights Templar?
Not in the sense of a new verdict. The Chinon Parchment of 1308 shows that papal cardinals absolved the Templar leaders, and the 1312 suppression was not a conviction for heresy. The 2007 Vatican publication simply made these records available.
What is the Chinon Parchment?
It is the record of an inquiry held at Chinon Castle in August 1308, in which three cardinals heard the Templar leaders and granted them absolution on behalf of Pope Clement V.
Who discovered the Chinon Parchment?
Italian historian Barbara Frale identified the original document in the Vatican archives in 2001.
Did the Pope ever apologise to the Templars?
No. There has been no formal papal apology or pardon. The 2007 publication was a scholarly facsimile edition.
Why did Clement V dissolve the order if he absolved its leaders?
Mainly because of political pressure from Philip IV and the damage the scandal had done. Vox in excelso dissolved the order by apostolic decree, not by judicial sentence.
Sources and Further Reading
- Barbara Frale, "The Chinon chart: Papal absolution to the last Templar, Master Jacques de Molay", Journal of Medieval History 30 (2004), 109–134.
- Processus contra Templarios, Exemplaria Praetiosa (Vatican Secret Archives and Scrinium, 2007).
- Malcolm Barber, The Trial of the Templars, 2nd edition (Cambridge University Press, 2006).
- Malcolm Barber and Keith Bate (trans.), The Templars: Selected Sources (Manchester University Press, 2002).
- Helen Nicholson, The Knights Templar on Trial: The Trial of the Templars in the British Isles, 1308–1311 (The History Press, 2009).
- Dan Jones, The Templars (Viking, 2017).
Shop the Templar Collection
Inspired by the history of the Order: hand-picked pieces from the Templar Blog store.

Milites Christi Knights Templar Tee
From $35.70

Knights Templar Ceramic Mug
From $24.00
Browse all Templar apparel → · Browse the full Templar collection
Related reading
Follow Templar Blog on Facebook for new Templar stories.

3 comments
DeMolay, finally exonerated after all these centuries, God damn it’s just the beginning
I would like to open up a dialogue with your organization regarding the Magdalene Blood Line. I have grown up with the stories of the Templars since my youth, influencing me to become a freemason and join the templars thereafter. I have since retired from masonry for various reasons but believe we can open up new frontiers with this exoneration.
Great to have posted this. People have to reminded of history and the evil people with power can use to their advantage.